Gourmet Cookie Trays

Have you ever tried a chocolate dipped butter cookie, an amaretti, or a lemon zing? They taste as good as they sound. Don’t take our word for it - try them yourself. Gourmet cookies are just $13.95 per pound.

Traditional Cookie Trays

Can’t decide on just one cookie? Try a traditional assorted cookie tray. Our two pound trays have 30 to 40 cookies, while our four pound trays have 60 to 80 cookies.

Shaped Cookies

Need a custom shaped cookie for you next themed party or special occasion? Cookies shaped like wedding cakes, baby onesies, and purses...we do it all. Simple shaped cookies start at $1.95 each. Be sure to place your order 7 days in advance.

Butter Cookies

Our butter cookies will bring a smile to your lips and melt in your mouth. Stop in and pick up a cookie to soothe your sweet tooth, or grab a pound of any of our traditional cookies for just $11.95.

Quick Links

Schedule A Wedding Cake Consultation

Wedding Cake FAQs

Party Cake FAQs

Creative Cakes Pricing

Join Our Email List

Connect with Us

We love to hear that our cookies taste just like Mom's - it's what we live for.

We offer traditional and gourmet cookies. Traditional cookies are $11.95 per pound. Gourmet cookies are $13.95 per pound. Not all cookies may be available at all times.

Custom decorated cookies are available in a number of shapes. Simple custom shaped cookies begin at $1.95 each. Special order shapes need to be placed a minimum of 7 days in advance.

Traditional Cookies
Butter Cookies	Cheese Kolacky	Oatmeal Raisin
Chocolate Chip	Raspberry Kolacky	Peanut Butter
Apricot Kolacky	M & M	Spritz

Gourmet Cookies
Amaretti	Italian Wedding	Splenda Spritz
Biscotti	Lemon Zing	Spumoni
Chocolate Dipped Butter	Pinwheels
Cinnamon "S"	Snickerdoodles

Gluten Free Cookies New!
Triple Chips (7.5 oz)	$7.50
Oats 'n Raisins (7.5 oz)	$7.50
Sugar Buttons (7.5 oz)	$6.95
Lemon Buttons (7.5 oz)	$7.50
Brownie Cookie (4 oz)	$3.49

Assorted Cookie Trays
2 lb. traditional assorted cookie tray (approx. 30-40)	$26.95
2 lb. gourmet assorted cookie tray (approx. 30-40)	$31.95
4 lb. traditional assorted cookie tray (approx. 60-80)	$48.95
4 lb. gourmet assorted cookie tray (approx. 60-80)	$61.95